On The Table...

Submissions are on a rolling basis. Please support us by signing up and telling your friends. You can also purchase the books and products of our writers on the site. Look for contests throughout the year.

The Lunch Break Blog welcomes new contributors who celebrate writing and reading as a daily part of their nutrition. Submit your essays, short stories, poetry, book and television reviews and insights by becoming an active writer. There is a category for you. Sign Up and your words can become the next lunch conversation.

 

Want to see your company's ad here? Become an Advertising Partner with the Lunch Break Blog! See our Advertising page for more information

Editor's Picks

Beer

The Fall Brew Review

Fall beers contain fantastic flavors that complement the season perfectly.


Football

Eagles Football: Where Philly Still Exists

If I ever go to war, I want to go with Philadelphia Eagles fans.


Election Day

Patrick Edmonds' Guide to Sensible Voting: Look for a Face You Can Trust

I propose an alternative system that has guided me well through the voting process.

Lunch Break Videos

Friends of the Lunch Break


Books
  • Thirst
    Thirst
    by Michael J Shay
  • What Baseball Teaches: A Poetic Odyssey into the 2008 World Series Champions Philadelphia Phillies
    What Baseball Teaches: A Poetic Odyssey into the 2008 World Series Champions Philadelphia Phillies
    by Michael J Shay
  • Philly War Zone: Growing Up in a Racial Battleground
    Philly War Zone: Growing Up in a Racial Battleground
    by Kevin Purcell
  • 97 MIles South
    97 MIles South
    by Phil Thompson
  • Steve Jobs
    Steve Jobs
    by Walter Isaacson
  • The Power and the Glory
    The Power and the Glory
    by Graham Greene

« Dean Green's Alaskan Salmon and Southwest Cod | Main | Interview with Philadelphia CowShare »
Thursday
Sep222011

Should We Lower The Drinking Age?

SteFou!Is beer the enemy?

I think the issue of the drinking age has a lot of moving parts.  Setting the drinking age to where it is today wasn’t simply picking a number out of a hat.  There were issues of health, politics, industry and even culture that went into the equation.

Health is probably one of the biggest concerns as alcohol can cause detrimental effects to the brain during key developmental periods.  The human brain doesn’t stop developing and maturing until 25 years of age and drinking and abusing alcohol can cause some long term detrimental effects.  As the alcohol content rises in the bloodstream different parts of the brain are affected: the cerebral cortex (inhibiting thought thus making it hard to think properly), then the cerebellum (making it hard to keep your balance), next is the hypothalamus and pituitary (increase in sexual urges) and finally the medulla (causing sleepiness, slower breathing and lower body temperature).  In the short-term, “blackouts” can occur resulting in memory lapses but long-term risks can lead to permanent damage such as the brain shrinking and deficiencies in the fibers that transmit information to the brain cells (HowStuffWorks).

I have been wondering whether lowering the drinking age would even help the alcohol industry all that much.  I think it would to some extent because you basically open the floodgates to a larger population but do I think that lowering the drinking age would help revive the large brewing companies like Anheuser-Busch or MillerCoors?  Not entirely but I think it could provide a bit of cash flow because kids could purchase alcohol from grocery stores instead of stealing from Mom and Dad’s fridge.  I also believe that if the large brewers thought this would help their sales then we would be hearing more noise about it (they have a lot of lobbying power).  The largest beer market segment is between the ages of 35-44 years old, who make up 23.2% of the beer drinking market (according to IBISWorld).  This means that even if the drinking age was lowered to 18, they probably wouldn’t become a large part of the beer drinking segment anyway.

Time Pearce, Los GatosI do however think that a lower drinking age would have a positive impact on craft beer and even homebrewing.  Young people would be able to buy beer that matches their palates and start developing their own tastes.  There would be no need to get the cheapest and most easily accessible beer anymore.  I also believe that homebrewing could become more of a family tradition and could be a positive teaching opportunity for parents and their children.

I feel that culture is the biggest issue with drinking in America.  Parents can sometimes make alcohol seem like the “forbidden fruit”.  This causes kids to want it more and may lead to problems of alcohol abuse.  Alcohol is supposed to enhance food and although it can sometimes serve as a social lubricant, it is misunderstood.  Parents should teach their children to respect and understand alcohol at home.  Drinking with your parents at dinner should no longer be frowned upon or something to brag to your friends about.  Having a glass of wine or beer at home should be commonplace.  I feel that this would help kids understand what wine and beer are meant for and how they can serve a purpose other than getting drunk.  Moderation and responsibility is key and if that can be taught instead of the “alcohol is evil approach” I believe we will all be better off.

Prohibition set alcohol back a long way because people during that time were simply drinking to get drunk as opposed to enjoying the occasional drink.  America also adopted this “abstinence only” educational approach to drinking.  They made alcohol seem to be the enemy and that anyone who partook in drinking (when they weren’t supposed to) were punished.  No one ever took the time to show people the attributes of alcohol and how it could enhance food.

With all things taken into consideration I believe the drinking age should be lowered to 18 or 19 in certain areas.  College campuses and military bases would be my main arguments as to where we could “test drive” the new policy.  These areas would allow for more oversight and control over the drinking process.  College campuses are rampant with underage drinking and if you were to lower the drinking to where freshman could consume alcohol with seniors it could become a much safer environment.  Instead of ripping shots and chugging beers secretly in a dorm room they can be served as adults on campus bars and regulated.  Colleges could also create on-campus bars that would allow students a place to go while bringing extra money into the school, providing a safe place for students and even provide learning opportunities for Hospitality Management students.

Kids are going to drink regardless of whether it’s legal or not (especially in college).  Why not provide a safer, more regulated way for them to do so?  No kid should ever have to worry about calling the ambulance because their underage friend is sick with alcohol poisoning.  We should try to repair the “alcohol is evil” mentality and put more emphasis on safer drinking habits as opposed to the “prohibition approach”.  Share and teach about wine, beer and spirits in a responsible way.

Reader Comments (3)

I am for lowering the drinking age. The age of adulthood is 18 because that is when Americans gain their power in the vote. Whether they are in school, the workforce, or the military shouldn't matter. In fact, depriving these Americans of their rights to eat and drink, and whatever else, keeps them in a state of dependency. I think a clear message for these young Americans would be to remove the drinking age limitations and encourage them to take an active role in government and their society.

I never understood why they do not allow 18 year olds to drink. I hope as a parent I can show my children an appreciation for alcohol, including beer, and how it can, as you say, elevate an experience and bond us together in jovial conversation or an event. This a poignant post.

September 24, 2011 | Registered CommenterJames Dugan

Dugan,

I think that was the whole anti-drunk driving/MADD movement in the early 1980's that really forced the issue on raising the drinking age. I would not want to be the politician that tries to run a platform on that. I am sure the reasoning is that you do not want a whole drop of 17 years olds just getting their license and also being able to get into bars. Though it brings it to your point that you can marry, vote, fight in a war and are considered an adult but cannot raise a glass of wine to celebrate? So silly.

I am in agreement...almost to the point where I do not think there should be a drinking age. Bars and restaurants can still choose based on age who they serve...but a child understanding how to responsibly drink at home and not treat it like this evil vice may be helpful in actually stemming drinking related issues. The fact that a parent can not allow his 16 year old to have a beer at a tailgate no matter how mature or responsible the 16 year old because the STATE said so is wrong, IMO.

Now I still always come back to the fact this ass-backwards nation allows alcohol but not marijuana. Deaths from alcohol abuse per year: usually somewhere around 100,000/year. Deaths from marijanua abuse per year...still waiting.

September 25, 2011 | Registered CommenterCJScalazetti

There is this cultural understanding that college kids drink. It clearly conflicts the drinking age of 21. Just look at college students who choose not to drink: I bet a poll would reveal the decision is made for moral or health reasons much more than for the fact that it is illegal. I wonder what percentage of our population just begins drinking at the age of 21.

I agree that lowering or eliminating the drinking age would be conducive to more responsible consumption.

September 25, 2011 | Registered Commenterbennythejetrodriguez

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.

My response is on my own website »
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
Post:
 
All HTML will be escaped. Hyperlinks will be created for URLs automatically.

A&E Books - Food - Health&Fit - Lit - Poetry - News - Sci&Tech - Life - Sports
About - RSS Feeds - Write - Advertise - Newsletter - Search - Log In - Sign Up
Contact - Terms of Use - Privacy Policy

Read MoreWrite MoreThink More

Want more Lunch Break? Please support us by signing up , telling your friends about LunchBreakBlog.com, becoming an advertiser, or making a donation to help keep our community growing.